Raising startup capital is rarely straightforward. The first challenge is convincing investors. The second, less glamorous challenge is deciding how to structure the deal. But before you even incorporate your startup, there’s an equally important decision — timing your incorporation can affect how and when you’re able to raise formally.

Founders often hear the terms convertible note, SAFE, and priced equity thrown around in early conversations but are rarely given a clear framework to choose between them. The reality is that the instrument you use to raise has long-term consequences. It affects how much equity you and your team keep, how attractive your company looks to future investors, and how smoothly your fundraising process unfolds. 

Many founders only realize the impact of their choice when they’re already negotiating a Series A or trying to clean up a messy cap table.

This guide is designed to be the single most comprehensive resource on the topic. It breaks down what each instrument is, how they compare, when to use them, and the mistakes to avoid. 

‍

What are convertible notes, SAFEs, and priced equity and why they matter

Before choosing, it’s essential to understand the fundamentals. Each option comes with different mechanics, risks, and implications.

Convertible Notes

A convertible note is debt that converts into equity at a later financing round. It’s called a “note” because it starts life as a loan from the investor to the company. The loan doesn’t stay debt forever; it converts to equity once you raise a priced round.

Core features:

• Debt instrument: Legally a loan until conversion.
  
  
• Maturity date: A timeline when the note either converts or is repaid.
  
  
• Interest rate: Typically 2–8 percent, accruing until conversion.
  
  
• Conversion mechanics: Converts into equity at a discount or capped valuation.
  
  

Convertible notes were the standard pre-seed/seed fundraising tool before SAFEs. They remain common outside Silicon Valley, where some investors still prefer the protections that come with debt.

‍

SAFEs (Simple Agreements for Future Equity)

The SAFE was introduced by Y Combinator in 2013 to simplify early-stage investing. Unlike a note, a SAFE is not debt. It carries no interest rate or maturity date. It simply promises future equity at the next priced round, usually with a discount or valuation cap.

Core features:

• Not debt: No maturity, no interest.
  
  
• Conversion: Converts into equity in a future priced round.
  
  
• Terms: Often includes a discount (e.g., 20%) or valuation cap.
  
  
• Founder-friendly: Lower legal cost and faster to execute.
  
  

SAFEs quickly became the default in Silicon Valley, especially for pre-seed and early seed rounds, because they remove the burden of debt obligations while maintaining simplicity.

‍

Priced Equity

A priced round is the traditional form of raising venture capital. The company and investors agree on a valuation today, issue shares immediately, and update the cap table. This requires full legal documentation and often comes with investor rights and governance structures.

Core features:

• Immediate equity issuance: Shares are sold at an agreed price per share.
  
  
• Valuation set today: Dilution is clear from day one.
  
  
• Full documentation: Shareholders agreements, voting rights, board seats.
  
  
• Higher cost and complexity: Legal and financial diligence required.
  
  

Priced rounds are unavoidable at later stages. They become common at Series A and sometimes at late-seed when institutional investors enter the picture.

How they compare at a glance

Here’s a summary comparison across the dimensions that matter most to founders:

The decision-making framework

1. Stage and traction

• Pre-seed / early seed: SAFEs or convertible notes are common. At this point, valuation is harder to set and speed is a priority.
  
  
• Late seed / Series A: Priced rounds are expected, especially if institutional investors are involved.
  
  

2. Speed vs certainty

• If the priority is to close fast with minimal legal cost, a SAFE is optimal.
  
  
• If investors want legal protections, or you want a maturity backstop, a note may be appropriate.
  
  
• If you want full clarity on ownership now, go with a priced round.
  
  

3. Investor base and expectations

• Angel investors and accelerators are often comfortable with SAFEs.
  
  
• Traditional venture funds may push for priced equity earlier.
  
  
• Certain geographies lean toward notes over SAFEs due to local norms.
  
  

Step-by-step guide to choosing and implementing the right structure

Step 1: Define your fundraising objective

• Is this a bridge round to extend runway? → SAFEs or notes fit.
  
  
• Is this your main seed round? → SAFEs may still work, but priced rounds bring clarity.
  
  
• Are you at Series A or later? → Expect a priced round.
  
  

Step 2: Test investor preferences early

Bring up structure in initial conversations. Some investors will only invest through their preferred instrument. Don’t wait until closing to discover this.

Step 3: Run dilution models

Use spreadsheets to model how much equity you and your co-founders will own under different scenarios. SAFEs and notes push dilution into the future, making it easy to underestimate.

Pro Tip:

Always model conversion at both the cap and the discount. This helps you anticipate worst-case dilution scenarios if your priced round valuation is lower than expected.

Step 4: Get legal alignment

• For SAFEs: YC’s open-source templates are widely accepted.
  
  
• For notes: Negotiate fair terms on interest and maturity. Avoid punitive structures.
  
  
• For priced rounds: Budget for higher legal costs and more negotiation time.
  
  

Step 5: Keep your cap table clean

Even if you raise with SAFEs or notes, keep records updated and plan for conversion in the next priced round. Cap table chaos is one of the biggest blockers to Series A.

Common mistakes to avoid

Mistake 1: Stacking too many SAFEs or notes

Founders sometimes issue multiple SAFEs across different valuations and terms. When they all convert, the cap table becomes unpredictable and unattractive to future investors.

Solution: Limit the number of different instruments, and consolidate before raising a priced round.

Mistake 2: Underestimating dilution from valuation caps

A SAFE with a $5M cap can look great when raising, but if your Series A is at $15M, those early investors convert at $5M and take a much larger chunk than you modeled.

Solution: Carefully negotiate caps, and always model both best- and worst-case outcomes.

Mistake 3: Using a priced round prematurely

If you set a valuation too early, you risk mispricing the company. A high valuation without traction makes the next round difficult. A low valuation locks in unnecessary dilution.

Solution: Delay priced rounds until you have traction and data to justify valuation.

Mistake 4: Treating SAFEs as “free money”

Because SAFEs don’t carry maturity or interest, some founders treat them casually. But every SAFE represents dilution waiting to happen.

Solution: Track SAFEs diligently. Use cap table software to simulate future ownership.

Advanced considerations

Discounts vs valuation caps

• Discounts give early investors shares at a reduced price (e.g., 20%) compared to the next round.
  
  
• Valuation caps set a maximum price at which the investment converts. Investors typically expect one or both.
  
  

MFN (Most Favored Nation) clauses

Some SAFEs and notes include MFN clauses, meaning if you later issue better terms to new investors, earlier ones can opt in. Founders often overlook this.

Post-money vs pre-money SAFEs

• Pre-money SAFEs: Earlier standard, could cause more dilution than expected.
  
  
• Post-money SAFEs: Newer version, makes founder dilution easier to calculate upfront.
  
  

Geographic norms

• In the US, SAFEs dominate pre-seed.
  
  
• In Europe, convertible notes remain common.
  
  
• In some markets, priced rounds happen earlier due to regulatory or cultural preferences.
  
  

FAQs founders ask

Q: Can I raise both SAFEs and notes at the same time?
Yes, but it complicates conversion and cap table management. Pick one instrument per round if possible.

Q: When do SAFEs convert into equity?
At the next priced round that meets the definition of an equity financing, usually a seed or Series A.

Q: Do convertible notes always need to be repaid?
Not if they convert. But if no qualifying round occurs before maturity, investors could demand repayment.

Q: Do priced rounds always require a lead investor?
Typically yes. A lead sets terms, valuation, and often takes a board seat.

Conclusion and next steps

Choosing between a convertible note, a SAFE, and a priced equity round is one of the most strategic early financing decisions a founder will make. It influences dilution, investor dynamics, and the path to future rounds.

Key takeaways:

• SAFEs are fastest and simplest, but delay clarity on ownership.
  
  
• Convertible notes add debt mechanics that can pressure founders later.
  
  
• Priced rounds provide certainty, but at the cost of time and money.
  
  
• Your choice depends on stage, fundraising goals, and investor base.
  
  

Founders should model outcomes, understand implications, and avoid kicking problems into the future. A clean, predictable cap table is one of the strongest signals to institutional investors.

For more hands-on tools, sign up for our newsletter and get our free Startup Fundraising Checklist to help you prepare your round with confidence.